Bahahaha Warcraft Newb =D
No wonder they didn't like it. They stumbled into f2p!
Just teasing

I guess the purpose of your fake was to show the difference in graphics between rune-a-scape and war-a-craft, which is a conundrum really. The nice enhanced graphics of the warcraft characters make runescape look so .... plain ..... causing your fake to appear fake anyway.
There is one thing I hear often when warcrafters log back into runescape (you are one of them) - god its hard to walk in this world! Now that would have been a great addition to your fake giving it more credibility.
Based on that, great work! and yes I am biased. I think your concept is a brilliant idea.
So overall: concept, method, fake is a 10/10 for me.
Btw, don't eat my chocolate cookies I left in the cupboard at home. I know you wanna but think twice before you do. I expect it to still be there next time I visit

.
Rae