I'll just leave an example:

Supernub: Gimme my Ipod back!
Weirdonub: I would, but I put it in the blender by mistake...
Weirdonub: Gimme my pie back!
Crazynub: I would, but I ate it...

and so forth.

I'll start.

Gimme my Giant Mechanical Duck Back!

Isn't this the same as Mstr Bllr's "Corrupt A Wish" game?

Probably but ill carry this on

I would but..well....look behind you?
gimme my flowers back!

Whoops, I ate them

Gimme mah bucket!

Sorry but this game seems to be very and if not almost identical to the corrupt a wish game. Though this topic is a very good idea, having 2 almost identical topics seems a bit silly so I'll close this one and just continue on corrupt a wish.

Thanks
~closed