Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Iran offered a Nuclear Bargain
RuneCrypt Forum > General Board > Debate Room
Saebjorn
Full article here.

QUOTE
NDON: Iran offered to stop aiding attacks on Western forces in Iraq if the West dropped opposition to its nuclear program, a top British official says.

Sir John Sawers, Britain's ambassador to the United Nations, told the BBC that Iranian officials had privately admitted their role in supporting insurgents' roadside bomb attacks on British and US troops.

But Britain rejected the proposed deal, floated in meetings at London hotels.

"The Iranians wanted to be able to strike a deal whereby they stopped killing our forces in Iraq in return for them being allowed to carry on with their nuclear program," Sir John said in a BBC TV documentary on Saturday.

He paraphrased the terms of the proposed deal as: "We stop killing you in Iraq, stop undermining the political process there, you allow us to carry on with our nuclear program without let or hindrance."

The proposal came in a series of meetings between Iranian and European officials, he said.

"There were various Iranians who would come to London and suggest we have tea in some hotel or other. They'd do the same in Paris, they'd do the same in Berlin, and then we'd compare notes among the three of us."

The news agency Mehr quoted an Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman, Hassan Ghashghavi, as saying in response that the country's authorities "have many times stressed that Iran has no role in attacks on American and British troops".

"The Islamic Republic of Iran from the beginning of the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq has played a role for the return of peace, stability and calm in these countries," he said. "It had regular dialogues and co-operation with international forces with regard to these issues."

The claim is one of several in the documentary about backroom talks between the West and Iran since 2001.

Quoting Iranian and US officials, the program also said Tehran co-operated closely with the US to oust the Taliban in Afghanistan after the September 11 attacks, even providing intelligence to help with bombing raids.

Inside Iraq the Government has reopened the infamous Abu Ghraib prison, promising decent conditions including a gym, computer chatroom and hair salon.

The Baghdad prison, which gained global notoriety in 2004 after US jailers filmed themselves tormenting and sexually abusing Iraqi prisoners, was shut down two years ago for refurbishment when the US handed control of it to the new Iraqi government.

Agence France-Presse; Telegraph, London
Row
No easy answer in that situation.
bling_masta8
Just Iran testing the West's willingness to halt its nuclear program I guess.
Tyranno
You serious?

Those Iranians are just having a laugh now surely.
I am me and only me
In other words: Death now or death later?
Saebjorn
Even worse, however-you-say-your-name-in-short.

"Heres the deal. We stop killing you now and MASS PWN THE WORLD LATER, or we kill you now and dont mass pwn the world later."
bling_masta8
QUOTE(Saebjorn @ Feb 24 2009, 06:14 AM) *

Even worse, however-you-say-your-name-in-short.

"Heres the deal. We stop killing you now and MASS PWN THE WORLD LATER, or we kill you now and dont mass pwn the world later."
He's IAMOAM wink.gif

How do you know Iran is building a nuke?
Overdoziz
Nuke Iran; problem solved. sleep.gif
h3n7y
Ahmadinejad is the world's greatest troll. Iran isn't going to do anything, to the "west", he wind's the "west" and particularly America, up, because that's what pleases the Supreme Leader and his followers.
I am me and only me
QUOTE(bling_masta8 @ Feb 24 2009, 06:54 AM) *
QUOTE(Saebjorn @ Feb 24 2009, 06:14 AM) *

Even worse, however-you-say-your-name-in-short.

"Heres the deal. We stop killing you now and MASS PWN THE WORLD LATER, or we kill you now and dont mass pwn the world later."
He's IAMOAM wink.gif

How do you know Iran is building a nuke?


IAMAOM or just Abi

How do we know it's a nuke?

"allow us to carry on with our nuclear program"

What else would they possibly be doing?
Rob
Nuclear Power. It's quite a useful method of creating electricity - and actually a fairly clean one regardless of what greenpeace might say about it. Yes you have nuclear waste, but there's radiation around us every minute of every day.

Personally I'd be far happier with suggesting that Iran be allowed to continue their nuclear programme, but that they submit to UN inspections in order to ascertain that they are simply generating electricity and nothing more sinister. Although as usual there's our usual case of double standards going on - we have nukes but our having them deters anyone else from launching a nuke. Yeah right. I'd be far more happy knowing that Iran was being inspected to ensure that they aren't building nukes rather than trusting they've not purchased weapons grade plutonium on the black market and built a dirty bomb in secret. Far easier to prepare against the threat you know is there than the one you can't see and all that.
I am me and only me
QUOTE(Rob @ Feb 24 2009, 05:19 PM) *
Nuclear Power. It's quite a useful method of creating electricity - and actually a fairly clean one regardless of what greenpeace might say about it. Yes you have nuclear waste, but there's radiation around us every minute of every day.

Personally I'd be far happier with suggesting that Iran be allowed to continue their nuclear programme, but that they submit to UN inspections in order to ascertain that they are simply generating electricity and nothing more sinister. Although as usual there's our usual case of double standards going on - we have nukes but our having them deters anyone else from launching a nuke. Yeah right. I'd be far more happy knowing that Iran was being inspected to ensure that they aren't building nukes rather than trusting they've not purchased weapons grade plutonium on the black market and built a dirty bomb in secret. Far easier to prepare against the threat you know is there than the one you can't see and all that.


Why the hell would everyone by throwing such a fit if all they want to do is make energy? Christ I really have no idea whats going on...
as i lay dying
It starts with nuclear energy. Then they weoponize it. No, I think Iran should'nt get nuclear freedom.
GJ on declining the bargain wink.gif
Rob
They say they want power, everyone else thinks they want nuclear weapons. Since it all requires nuclear facilities, no-one wants to let them continue with it.

I still love the fact that there's not the same furore over North Korea where they've actually been testing nuclear weapons because, apparently, China can keep them from using them for anything bad.
Zhou
A sustained nuclear reaction is the cornerstone of both a nuclear power plant as well as a nuclear bomb. Unfortunately, the US doesn't want to take that risk, and is too stubborn to negotiate.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.