Call of Juarez : Bound in Blood got released around a month ago, but it didn't get alot of attention. I hesitated a while before buying it, mainly because the first CoJ was awful, but I eventually did. I've only played a few hours, but it is looking awesome, and it's an excellent alternative for the FPS'er who is tired of all the usual stuff.
So eh, I won't spoil anything for you, but the game is basically about two brothers, Ray and Thomas. They differ greatly, Ray being the more aggressive one and Thomas being agile. The game has some very good graphics, and the physics feel very good. Everything except horses move in a natural way, the amount of bullets you/your enemy can take isn't exaggerated, the A.I. is decent (sneaking up to you, staying in cover). The story is definitely enough to keep you going aswell. I'd give it a 8.7/10 and recommend it to everybody who needs a new, refreshing game.
Useful links : the GT review and the IGN review.